Tag: basic

Basics of Mixing – 10.1 Modulation Effects (Part 1)

Hi everyone! This is Jooyoung Kim, a mixing engineer and music producer.

Today, I want to talk about modulation effects, which are often overlooked during mixing.

(These concepts are based on my book Basics of Mixing, published in Korea.)

What are Modulation Effects?

In simple terms, modulation effects involve changing certain parameters over time.

Do you frequently use modulation effects when composing or mixing?

Do you ever have tools like these but rarely touch them?

I believe modulation effects, along with reverb and delay, are crucial in determining the quality of a track. However, even if you understand the theory behind these effects, you might hesitate to use them if you’re unfamiliar with how they sound in practice.

That’s why I encourage you to experiment with modulation effects regularly, even if it feels forced at first.

Types of Modulation Effects

Let’s break down some common modulation effects:

  1. Tremolo
  2. Vibrato
  3. Flanger
  4. Phaser
  5. Chorus

Before diving into these, we need to discuss two foundational concepts: the All-Pass Filter and the Comb Filtering Effect.

All-Pass Filter

An all-pass filter allows all frequencies to pass through unchanged. But why would we use such a filter?

The answer lies in phase.

When a signal passes through an all-pass filter, the phase shifts depending on the frequency. Combining this filtered signal with the original creates unique sounds due to constructive and destructive interference at different frequencies.

For more details on phase and interference, check out “Basics of Mixing – 2.2 Phase and Interference.”

Comb Filtering Effect

The comb filtering effect occurs when an original signal is combined with a delayed version of itself. This results in a frequency response that looks like the teeth of a comb.

It’s easy to understand this concept through simple experiments.

When every frequency in a signal is delayed by the same amount, some frequencies cancel out (destructive interference), while others amplify (constructive interference). This creates the characteristic comb-like frequency response.

Effects like flanger, phaser, and chorus are built on these principles of phase manipulation.

That’s all for now! In the next post, I’ll delve deeper into each modulation effect.

See you next time! 😊

Basics of Mixing – 9.1 Harmonics and Saturation

Hello, I’m Jooyoung Kim, an audio engineer and music producer.

Today, I’d like to talk about two crucial aspects of sound: harmonics and coloration. As audio engineers, we know from experience—and from measurements—that the audio signal changes when it passes through hardware or plugins.

For example, why do sounds processed through vacuum tubes and tape machines end up so different from each other?

It’s a topic worth considering for anyone involved in sound production: how exactly does the signal change, and why?

Of course, if it sounds good, that’s all that matters. But if we take that approach, we could say the same for EQs and compressors—if it sounds good, it’s good enough, right?

That said, this chapter will focus on explaining the devices that introduce coloration to sound.

When an analog audio signal passes through analog devices, harmonics are generated due to the non-linear behavior of these devices.

OP Amp
Vacuum Tubes

For example, when components like transistors (such as OP Amps) or vacuum tubes are part of the circuit, they create non-linear responses in the output, which results in harmonic distortion.

Legendary Marinair Transformer used in Neve Hardware (Photo from AMS Neve)

If you’re a fan of hardware, you’ve probably heard the term “transformer.” When you insert a transformer like the one shown above at the input or output stage of hardware, it creates non-linearities that result in harmonics.

This is why different components alter the character of a device, and why those who modify gear often swap out transformers, tubes, or transistors!

Why do non-linear behaviors generate harmonics? We could explain this through Fourier analysis, but I’ll spare you the math to keep things interesting.

(If you’re curious, look up non-linear systems and functions.)

Harmonics

If you’ve studied music, you might recall learning about harmonics and harmonic series in class. Generally speaking, even-order harmonics sound more harmonious and pleasant, while odd-order harmonics tend to create dissonance and can sound harsher.

So, if a device emphasizes odd-order harmonics, it will sound sharper. On the other hand, if it emphasizes even-order harmonics, it will blend more smoothly into the mix.

Now, are there analog devices that exclusively boost even or odd harmonics? Not really.

UA 1176LN Legacy Plugin that boosts only odd harmonics

As shown above, you’ll find this kind of control in plugins, but not in analog hardware.

Additionally, because of non-linear responses, the levels of second, third, fourth, and other harmonics also vary in non-linear ways.

So how should we understand these devices? Do vacuum tubes and transistors have unique characteristics?

We’ll continue exploring these questions in the next post.

Basics of Mixing – 8.3 How to Use Reverb?

Hello, this is Jooyoung Kim, music producer and audio engineer.

Last time, we explored the history and types of reverb. Today, we’ll dive into the practical ways to use reverb in your mix. Let’s get started!

When you first open a reverb plugin, the numerous settings can be overwhelming. But in reality, you only need to focus on three key parameters:

  1. Pre-Delay
  2. RT60 (Reverb Time)
  3. Type of Reverb

Pre-Delay refers to how much time passes between the original sound and the reverb effect. If the listener is close to the sound source, a larger Pre-Delay feels natural, while a smaller Pre-Delay is ideal if the source is far away.

RT60 measures the time it takes for the sound to decay by 60dB. While the decay time can vary depending on the frequency, you can generally think of it as the time for the reverb to fade out.

Reverb types are crucial because they give your mix different atmospheres depending on the choice. Knowing these basics should be enough to get you started!

Understanding Reverb Parameters
Here’s RVerb, a basic digital reverb plugin from Waves.

Time represents RT60, but what about Size? Size controls the virtual space’s dimensions, affecting the initial reflections and how the reverb tail forms.

Diffusion varies across plugins. It manages whether the reverb tail is formed by the direct sound or by the reflections. Lower values make the tail clearer and less cluttered, while higher values create a fuller sound.

Decay isn’t always present, so we’ll skip that for now. Early Reflections control how strong the initial echoes are. Smaller rooms produce stronger early reflections, while larger rooms have weaker ones. Wall materials can also affect this.

Reverbs like Shimmer add pitch modulation, Plate and Spring reverbs adjust materials, and Chamber reverbs may let you adjust mic and speaker positions.

With IR (Impulse Response) reverbs, drastic changes to settings like Pre-Delay can feel unnatural, so if you’re not satisfied with the sound, it’s better to switch to a different reverb entirely.

Reverb EQ

There’s a reason why many reverb plugins include built-in EQs.

When applying reverb, EQ is key. Think of a live concert venue like a club in Hongdae. Outside, you mostly hear bass, while the vocals are hard to make out, right? This is because low frequencies travel further, while high frequencies lose energy faster in the air.

To simulate the natural acoustics of a real venue, especially for orchestral performances, applying EQ to the reverb can help create a more realistic reverb effect. Additionally, reducing some lows and mids from the reverb will help prevent the reverb from muddying up your mix, allowing for a clearer sound.

Reverb Compression & Saturation

What happens when you apply compression to reverb? Compression reduces dynamic range, which gives the illusion of a longer reverb tail, making it feel like the reverb lasts longer.

You can also add tonal color through hardware or plugin saturation to alter the feel of the reverb. For example, sidechaining the reverb to a vocal or lead instrument can reduce the reverb when those elements are prominent, and increase it when they are not.

Gated Reverb

By using a gate, you can tightly control the reverb to match the groove of the track. Using sidechain techniques with gates or envelope followers, you can craft tight, precise reverb effects. This technique works wonders in genres like funk, but it can feel out of place in ballads—so choose carefully!

Various Reverb Uses

It’s common to use more than one reverb in a mix. For instance, a UAD Precision Reflection Engine can add artificial ambience to dry tracks, while you might apply a Plate Reverb specifically to the snare drum.

For consistency, you might apply a Hall Reverb across all elements in the mix. And don’t forget to adjust your Send Panning for spatial accuracy.

That’s about it for reverb usage! While theory helps, there’s no substitute for hands-on experience. Keep experimenting, and I’m sure you’ll get the hang of it.

Until next time, see you in the next post! 😊

Basics of Mixing – 7.1 What is Delay?

Hello! This is Jooyoung Kim, an mixing engineer and music producer. Today, I want to delve into the time effect known as delay.

Shall we get started?

So, what exactly is delay?

It’s simple, really. Delay is an effect that repeats the same sound with a time difference.

Why would we use this effect, though? There are several reasons, which can be summarized as follows:

  1. Using only reverb can sometimes create unnatural reverb tails.
  2. The feedback feature allows for the creation of very long reverb tails.
  3. It can add an artificial groove to a source.
  4. Special delay effects can be applied to instruments (especially common with electric guitars, and can also be used with short delays).

Effectively using delay can create a rich and natural reverb. If you’ve only been using reverb to add space to your mix, try incorporating delay as well.

I personally favor UAD’s Precision Delay because it lets you set the delay time in seconds rather than adjusting it via feedback. By setting the delay time similarly to RT60, which I’ll discuss in the reverb section, the sound can fade naturally.

Using a delay plugin to set the pre-delay instead of the reverb plugin’s pre-delay can also be effective. Especially if the reverb plugin doesn’t allow synchronization of the pre-delay time with the BPM, you can achieve a precise pre-delay using a delay plugin that does.

Setting a very short delay with minimal feedback and then filtering out high and low frequencies, while adjusting the volume, can create a subtle groove that wasn’t originally show in the source. This can add a sticky, rhythmic feel to percussion, which is particularly useful in genres like R&B and hip-hop.

Using historical replica delays can also help recreate the vintage sound of old-school or retro music.

There are countless crucial aspects of mixing, but I believe that handling reverb effectively is one of the key factors that define the quality of a sound. However, this is an area that’s hard to explain solely with words. You really have to experiment with various delay and reverb plugins to grasp it fully. It’s a challenging aspect, even for me.

Today, we’ll wrap up with this brief overview of delay. See you in the next post!